Skip to main content

Imposter Scams: When the Caller Isn't Who They Say They Are

 


Fraud Prevention Series | Article #1

By Detective A.J. Bradburn, MIAAI

STOP. DISCONNECT. VERIFY.

Your phone rings.

The caller tells you they are with your bank. There has been suspicious activity on your account, your money is at risk, and you need to act immediately.

Another caller identifies himself as a police officer. You are told that you missed jury duty and there is now a warrant for your arrest. Fortunately, the caller says, you can resolve the warrant by paying a fine.

Or maybe the voice on the other end of the phone sounds like a family member. They have been arrested, injured, or involved in an accident. They need money—and they need it right now.

The stories are different, but the strategy is the same:

The scammers want to convince you that the person contacting you is someone you can trust, they will try to create fear or urgency, and then get you to act before you have time to verify the story.

These are imposter scams, and they are one of the most commonly reported forms of fraud in the United States.

According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), consumers reported losing approximately $3.5 billion to imposter scams in 2025. More than one million imposter-scam reports were made that year, accounting for nearly one out of every three fraud reports received by the FTC.

Those numbers represent reported losses. Many fraud incidents go unreported.

What Is an Imposter Scam?

An imposter scam occurs when a criminal pretends to be a person or organization you recognize or trust in an attempt to obtain money, financial information, personal identifying information, or access to your accounts.

The scammer may pretend to be:

  • A police officer, sheriff's deputy, FBI agent, IRS employee, or other government official
  • Your bank or credit union
  • A credit card company
  • A utility company or other familiar business
  • A technical-support representative
  • An employer
  • A family member
  • An attorney representing a family member
  • A representative of a legitimate company

One of the things that can make these scams so convincing is that the person contacting you may already know information about you.

They might know your name, address, employer, relatives, or other personal details.

Knowing accurate information about you does not prove that the person contacting you is legitimate.

Let's take a look at how the scam works.

Although the story may change, many imposter scams follow the same basic pattern.

1. They will attempt to establish Trust or Authority

The scammer first needs you to believe they are someone you should trust—or someone you should fear ignoring.

They may identify themselves as a detective, federal agent, bank fraud investigator, government employee, attorney, or representative of a company you recognize.

They may provide a name, badge number, employee identification number, case number, or other information designed to make the contact sound official.

2. Next they will Create a Problem

Next, the scammer gives you something to worry about.

Your bank account has supposedly been compromised.

Your Social Security number has allegedly been connected to criminal activity.

You missed jury duty.

There is a warrant for your arrest.

Your computer or online account has been compromised.

A family member has been arrested or injured.

The specific story isn't nearly as important as what happens next.

3. After they have introduced the problem they will Create Urgency

Now the pressure begins.

The scammer wants you to believe something terrible will happen unless you act right now.

You may be threatened with arrest, loss of money, suspension of an account, disconnection of a service, or some other serious consequence.

Some scammers will tell victims not to hang up. Others will instruct them not to speak with their bank, family members, police, or anyone else about what is happening.

There is a reason for that.

Time and independent verification are enemies of the scammer.

The longer you have to think about the situation—and the more likely you are to talk to someone else—the greater the chance that the scam will fall apart.

4. Finally, they will Provide the "Solution"

Finally, the scammer tells you how to solve the problem they just created.

You may be instructed to:

  • Transfer money
  • Send a wire transfer
  • Purchase gift cards
  • Buy cryptocurrency
  • Withdraw cash
  • Move money to a supposedly "safe" or "secure" account
  • Provide banking information
  • Provide passwords or verification codes
  • Click a link and log into an account

At this point, the purpose of the entire story becomes clear.

The emergency was designed to convince you to give the scammer money, information, or access.

Don't Trust Your Caller ID

One of the most important things to understand about modern telephone fraud is this:

The number displayed on your phone does not prove who is calling you.

Criminals can manipulate caller ID information through a technique commonly known as spoofing. We will cover spoofing in a future article. 

Your phone might display the name or actual telephone number of a police department, government agency, bank, or business even though the caller has absolutely no connection to that organization.

The FBI continues to warn that government and law-enforcement impersonators use spoofed telephone numbers, email addresses, employee names, and credentials to make their stories more convincing.

The same principle applies online. Fraudulent emails, websites, text messages, and social-media accounts can be designed to closely resemble legitimate organizations.

Caller ID is not identity verification.

Watch for the Red Flags

Be cautious whenever an unexpected caller, text, email, or social-media message:

  • Creates an immediate emergency
  • Threatens arrest or other serious consequences
  • Tells you not to hang up
  • Tells you not to contact your bank, police, family members, or anyone else
  • Demands immediate payment
  • Requests payment by gift card, cryptocurrency, wire transfer, payment application, courier, or cash
  • Tells you to withdraw or transfer money for "safekeeping"
  • Requests passwords, PINs, or verification codes
  • Sends you a link and tells you to log into an account
  • Claims your money needs to be moved to a "safe" or "secure" account

The scammer's story will change.

The warning signs usually do not. These warning signs will normally stay constant in one form or another.

Here is YOUR action plan to help keep you from falling victim to these scammers. 

STOP. DISCONNECT. VERIFY.

If you remember only three words from this article, remember these:

STOP.

Don't allow someone else's sense of urgency to become your sense of urgency.

Before sending money, providing information, clicking a link, or following instructions, stop.

Give yourself time to think. We make better decisions when we slow down and give ourselves time to process. 

DISCONNECT.

End the communication. Be it text, email or phone call. 

It is perfectly acceptable to hang up on someone claiming to be a police officer, government employee, bank investigator, or company representative.

If the contact is legitimate, you can independently contact that organization. This will lead you to the independent verification stage of this process.

Do not remain on the telephone simply because someone tells you not to hang up.

VERIFY.

This is the most important step!!!

Contact the organization the person claimed to represent using contact information you obtain independently.

Do not use a telephone number, website, or link supplied by the suspicious caller, text message, or email.

If someone claims to represent your bank, use the telephone number printed on your debit or credit card, your bank statement, or the institution's official website or mobile application.

If someone claims to be a police officer, independently locate the agency's official telephone number. Call the agency yourself and verify the officer's identity and the reason for the contact.

If someone claims that a family member is in trouble, contact that family member directly or speak with another trusted relative before sending money.

A few minutes spent verifying a story could prevent a financial loss that may be extremely difficult—or impossible—to recover.

"But They Knew Information About Me"

This is one of the reasons imposter scams can be so convincing.

Personal information can come from numerous sources, including data breaches, compromised accounts, social media, public records, phishing attacks, commercially available information, and previous fraud schemes.

A caller knowing your name, address, family members, employer, or other information should not automatically establish trust.

Instead of concentrating on what the person knows about you, pay attention to what the person is asking you to do.

That distinction can be extremely important.

Technology Is Making Impersonation More Convincing

The technology used by fraudsters continues to evolve.

The FBI has warned that criminals are using artificial intelligence and other technologies to make impersonation schemes appear more legitimate. This can include AI-generated video, fake websites, manipulated communications, and voices designed to sound like real people.

In September 2026, the FBI again warned about widespread schemes involving criminals impersonating law-enforcement and government officials. Between January 2025 and July 2026, the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center received nearly 61,000 complaints involving law-enforcement or government impersonation scams, with reported losses exceeding $1.6 billion.

Technology can make a fraudulent communication look or sound extremely convincing.

That is why seeing a familiar face or hearing a familiar voice should not replace independent verification when an unexpected request involves money or sensitive information.

Technology changes.

The basic defense does not.

What If You've Already Sent Money?

If you realize that you may have been the victim of an imposter scam, act quickly.

Contact the bank, credit union, credit card company, payment service, cryptocurrency exchange, or other financial institution involved in the transaction.

Tell them you believe you were the victim of fraud and ask whether the transaction can be stopped, recalled, frozen, or otherwise recovered.

If you provided account credentials, change affected passwords immediately and enable multi-factor authentication when available.

If you provided personal identifying information, additional steps may be necessary to protect your identity and financial accounts.

You should also consider reporting the incident to your local law-enforcement agency.

Fraud can be reported to the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Internet-enabled fraud can also be reported to the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center at IC3.gov.

Preserve the Evidence

Before deleting suspicious messages, emails, or accounts, preserve as much information as possible.

Save:

  • Text messages and emails
  • Screenshots
  • Telephone numbers and email addresses
  • Usernames and social-media profiles
  • Website addresses
  • Transaction confirmations
  • Bank records
  • Gift-card receipts and card information
  • Cryptocurrency wallet addresses and transaction information
  • Names, badge numbers, employee numbers, or case numbers provided by the scammer
  • Dates and times of communications

Something that appears insignificant to you may become useful during an investigation.

The Bottom Line

Imposter scams work because criminals exploit trust, fear, authority, and urgency.

You don't have to determine exactly who is on the other end of the telephone before protecting yourself.

You don't have to confront the caller.

And you don't have to prove that it is a scam.

You simply need to recognize when something doesn't seem right and give yourself enough time to independently verify the story.

A legitimate organization should not object to you independently verifying who you are dealing with.

A scammer has every reason to prevent you from doing so.

STOP. DISCONNECT. VERIFY.

STOP before sending money or providing information.

DISCONNECT from the unexpected communication.

VERIFY the person or organization independently.


About the Author

Detective A.J. Bradburn, MIAAI is a law-enforcement investigator specializing in financial crimes and arson/fire investigations. His financial-crimes investigative responsibilities include fraud, forgery, theft, identity-related offenses, and other financially motivated crimes. He also conducts fire investigations involving fire origin and cause and suspected arson.

The Fraud Prevention Series draws upon his investigative experience to help individuals and businesses better understand common fraud schemes, recognize warning signs, and take practical steps to reduce their risk of becoming victims.

Disclaimer

This article is provided for general fraud-prevention and educational purposes only. The views expressed are those of the author and should not be interpreted as an official statement or policy of the author's employing agency or any other government organization.

This information is not intended as legal or financial advice. Specific incidents should be reported to the appropriate financial institution, law-enforcement agency, or regulatory authority.

Sources & Additional Resources

Federal Trade Commission
FTC Data Show People Reported Losing $3.5 Billion to Imposter Scams in 2025 — June 15, 2026.

Federal Trade Commission Consumer Advice
New Trends in Reports of Imposter Scams — May 2026.

Federal Bureau of Investigation / Internet Crime Complaint Center
Scammers Impersonating Law Enforcement and Government Officials in Fraud Schemes — September 17, 2026.

Federal Bureau of Investigation / Internet Crime Complaint Center
FBI Warns of Scammers Impersonating the IC3 — July 20, 2026.

Fraud reporting and consumer information are available through the Federal Trade Commission and the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center.


FRAUD PREVENTION SERIES

Detective A.J. Bradburn, MIAAI

STOP. DISCONNECT. VERIFY.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

STOP. DISCONNECT. VERIFY

  STOP. DISCONNECT. VERIFY. A Simple Three-Step Response to Suspicious Communications By Detective A.J. Bradburn, MIAAI Most of us learned a simple fire-safety lesson when we were young: Stop. Drop. Roll. It works because it's simple and easy to remember. It was drilled into us as kids. When someone is frightened or under pressure, complicated instructions can be difficult to remember. A short sequence of actions gives people something they can immediately do. Fraud prevention needs that same kind of simplicity. Scams are constantly changing. Criminals impersonate banks, government agencies, law enforcement officers, businesses, employers, technical-support representatives, family members and countless others. The technology changes too. Phone numbers can be spoofed. Emails and text messages can look legitimate. Websites can be copied. Personal information obtained from data breaches or other sources can make a scammer's story more convincing. Trying to reco...

Identity Theft & Identity Fraud: When Someone Uses Your Information

  Identity Theft & Identity Fraud: When Someone Uses Your Information By Detective A.J. Bradburn, MIAAI You receive an email thanking you for opening a new credit account. There's only one problem. You didn't open it. Maybe it's a text telling you that your password has been changed. A purchase appears on an account that you don't recognize. You receive a collection notice for a debt you've never heard of. Or you suddenly discover that you're locked out of your own email account. Identity-related crimes don't always begin when money disappears. Sometimes they begin much earlier— when someone obtains the information needed to pretend to be you. Identity Theft vs. Identity Fraud: What's the Difference? People commonly use the terms identity theft and identity fraud interchangeably. For fraud-prevention purposes, however, there is a useful distinction. Identity Theft Think of identity theft as the unauthorized obtaining or posse...